Css 2019

Log In

Sociology 2016

Q. No. 2: Discuss the Application of Sociology in Agriculture, Health, and Industries with Examples

Outline

  1. Introduction
  2. Sociology as an Applied Science
  3. Application of Sociology in Agriculture
    • Agrarian Social Structure
    • Land Reforms and Ownership Patterns
    • Rural Power Dynamics and Caste Systems
    • Technological Change and Farmer Behavior
    • Case Study: Pakistan’s Feudal Patterns
  4. Application of Sociology in Health
    • Medical Sociology
    • Health Beliefs, Practices, and Inequalities
    • Role of Culture in Health Behavior
    • COVID-19 and Sociological Impact
    • Example: Health Disparities in Pakistan
  5. Application of Sociology in Industry
    • Industrial Relations and Labor Sociology
    • Workplace Culture and Socialization
    • Gender and Class in Industrial Labor
    • Impact of Automation and Globalization
    • Case Study: Industrial Zones in Pakistan
  6. Interconnectedness of the Three Sectors
  7. Critical Evaluation
  8. Conclusion
  9. References
  1. Introduction

Sociology, as the scientific study of society, plays a crucial role in understanding the structures, processes, and changes within various domains of human activity. While traditionally focused on theoretical understanding, modern sociology has evolved to include applied dimensions, particularly in agriculture, health, and industrial development—sectors central to national growth and societal well-being.

This answer explores how sociological insights and tools are applied to analyze and improve outcomes in agriculture, health, and industries, with a focus on Pakistani context where applicable.

  1. Sociology as an Applied Science

Applied sociology involves the practical use of sociological theories and methods to address real-world problems. It seeks:

  • Solutions to social inequality
  • Better governance and public policy
  • Cultural understanding and behavior modification
  • Organizational and economic productivity
  1. Application of Sociology in Agriculture

Agriculture, especially in agrarian societies like Pakistan, is deeply social, governed by customs, kinship, caste, and power relations, more than just technical or economic decisions.

  1. Agrarian Social Structure
  • Sociologists study landholding patterns, tenant-lord relationships, and community organizations.
  • The zamindari system, patriarchy, and biradari (clan) networks influence agricultural decisions.
  1. Land Reforms and Ownership Patterns
  • Land is not just an economic asset but a symbol of status and power.
  • Sociological research helps understand resistance to land reforms due to entrenched feudal culture.

“Agriculture is not merely about crops—it is about culture, hierarchy, and power.” — A.R. Desai

  1. Rural Power Dynamics
  • Studies on rural sociology reveal how local panchayats, jirgahs, and political affiliations determine resource access and conflict resolution.
  1. Technology Adoption and Behavioral Patterns
  • Sociologists investigate why farmers resist or adopt new methods (e.g., GMO crops, irrigation systems).
  • Cultural beliefs, risk aversion, and lack of trust in institutions affect technology acceptance.
  1. Case Study: Feudal Agriculture in Pakistan
  • Over 40% of agricultural land is controlled by less than 5% of landlords.
  • Tenant farmers often work under informal arrangements, leading to social dependency and exploitation.
  1. Application of Sociology in Health

The field of medical sociology studies how social factors impact health, illness, healthcare access, and medical institutions.

  1. Health Beliefs and Practices
  • Sociologists analyze how culture, religion, education, and gender shape health-seeking behavior.
  • Beliefs in supernatural causes of illness still persist in rural areas.
  1. Inequality and Health Disparities
  • Poor, marginalized, or rural communities often face:
    • Inadequate healthcare access
    • Poor sanitation
    • Higher disease burden

Example: In Pakistan, maternal mortality rate is high among rural and underprivileged women.

  1. Culture and Disease
  • Sociological studies explore why some communities resist vaccination, as seen during polio campaigns in Pakistan due to religious misconceptions.
  1. COVID-19 as a Case Study
  • Sociologists studied:
    • Spread of misinformation
    • Stigmatization of patients
    • Trust deficit in government
    • Role of social media in shaping public behavior
  1. Gender and Health
  • Women are often excluded from decision-making, leading to poor health outcomes, malnutrition, and reproductive health issues.

“Health is a mirror of social justice in any society.” — Paul Farmer

  1. Application of Sociology in Industry

Industrial sociology analyzes how individuals and groups interact within the industrial and organizational settings.

  1. Labor Relations
  • Explores power dynamics between management and workers, including:
    • Wages
    • Unionization
    • Collective bargaining
    • Worker rights
  1. Workplace Socialization
  • How employees learn organizational culture, norms, and productivity ethics.
  • Influences behavior, loyalty, and job satisfaction.
  1. Gender and Class Inequality
  • Women often face:
    • Lower wages
    • Harassment
    • Glass ceiling
  • Class-based discrimination affects recruitment and promotion.
  1. Impact of Globalization
  • Sociological analysis reveals how outsourcing and automation reshape workforce structures.
  • Gig economy and informal labor have created new labor vulnerabilities.
  1. Case Study: Industrial Zones in Pakistan
  • In Karachi, Sialkot, and Faisalabad:
    • Lack of worker safety regulations
    • Long hours with low pay
    • Weak union representation
  • Sociological studies help advocate for ethical labor laws and reforms.
  1. Interconnectedness of Agriculture, Health, and Industry

These sectors are interdependent, and sociological analysis provides holistic solutions.

Sector

Sociological Contribution

Agriculture

Understand rural power, land reforms, and behavior change

Health

Address cultural stigma, inequality, and access

Industry

Improve labor rights, gender equity, workplace ethics

Example: A rural female worker might face landlessness (agriculture), lack of maternity support (health), and wage discrimination (industry)—all interlinked sociologically.

  1. Critical Evaluation

Strengths of Sociology in These Fields:

  • Offers contextual understanding beyond economics.
  • Incorporates cultural sensitivity and behavioral insight.
  • Promotes inclusive policymaking by giving voice to marginalized communities.

Challenges:

  • Policymakers often prioritize economic efficiency over social equity.
  • Sociological recommendations are seen as idealistic or “soft” science.
  • Lack of data and institutional support for sociological research in Pakistan.
  1. Conclusion

Sociology’s application in agriculture, health, and industry is indispensable for developing humane, inclusive, and sustainable systems. It provides a lens to see beyond numbers—to the people behind those numbers, shaped by culture, power, inequality, and resistance.

In a country like Pakistan—marked by agrarian roots, fragile health systems, and struggling industries—sociological insights are essential for understanding real-life dynamics and crafting responsive policies.

“Sociology brings people into focus—without which no policy, no economy, and no system can truly function.” — Anthony Giddens

Q. No. 3: Why is Social Stratification Inevitable for a Society? Explain Its Determinants in the Context of Pakistani Society.

Outline

  1. Introduction
  2. Defining Social Stratification
  3. Theoretical Perspectives on Stratification
    • Functionalist Perspective (Davis & Moore)
    • Conflict Perspective (Karl Marx, Max Weber)
    • Symbolic Interactionism
  4. Why Social Stratification is Inevitable
    • Role Differentiation and Allocation
    • Motivation and Social Order
    • Power Dynamics and Resource Scarcity
  5. Determinants of Social Stratification in General
    • Class, Status, Power
    • Gender, Ethnicity, Religion
    • Occupation, Education, Wealth
  6. Determinants of Social Stratification in Pakistan
    • Feudal and Tribal Heritage
    • Educational Disparities
    • Economic Inequality and Class Structure
    • Gender-Based Stratification
    • Religious and Sectarian Identity
    • Caste-like Stratification (Biradari System)
    • Urban-Rural Divide
  7. Impacts of Stratification on Pakistani Society
  8. Critical Analysis: Is Stratification Functional or Disruptive?
  9. Conclusion
  10. References
  1. Introduction

Every society, regardless of its ideology or development status, organizes individuals into hierarchies based on power, prestige, and privilege. This system of ranking is known as social stratification. It is not random; rather, it reflects deeply rooted structures of inequality that shape access to resources and opportunities.

This answer explains why social stratification is inevitable and examines its determinants in the context of Pakistan, where feudal legacies, class disparities, and cultural hierarchies perpetuate layered inequalities.

  1. Defining Social Stratification

Social stratification is the structured ranking of individuals and groups in society based on socio-economic status, power, ethnicity, gender, religion, and other factors. These ranks are institutionalized and influence one’s life chances.

“Stratification is not an accident; it is an institutionalized inequality.” – Melvin Tumin

  1. Theoretical Perspectives on Stratification
  2. Functionalist Perspective – Davis & Moore Thesis
  • Stratification is necessary and functional.
  • Society needs role differentiation; high-reward roles (e.g., doctors, judges) require more training, so must offer more incentives.
  • Stratification ensures the most qualified fill crucial positions.
  1. Conflict Perspective – Karl Marx
  • Stratification is a result of class conflict and capitalist exploitation.
  • Bourgeoisie (owners) control means of production; proletariat (workers) are oppressed.
  • Marx viewed stratification as a tool of domination.
  1. Max Weber’s View
  • Weber expanded Marx by adding status (prestige) and party (political power).
  • Stratification is multidimensional, not only economic.
  1. Symbolic Interactionism
  • Focuses on how people perceive class differences and use symbols (e.g., dress, language) to reinforce stratification.
  1. Why Social Stratification is Inevitable

Stratification emerges due to inherent social needs and structural limitations:

  1. Role Allocation
  • Societies need individuals to perform different roles. Not all jobs can be equally rewarded.
  • Inequality motivates training and performance.
  1. Scarcity of Resources
  • Land, wealth, education, and healthcare are limited.
  • Unequal distribution leads to class formation.
  1. Power Consolidation
  • Political elites and economic powers institutionalize stratification to maintain dominance.
  1. Social Order and Stability
  • Clear hierarchies reduce anomie and chaos.
  • Even democratic societies have stratified systems (e.g., based on merit).
  1. General Determinants of Social Stratification

Determinant

Explanation

Class

Income and wealth define social classes

Status

Social respect or prestige (e.g., scholars, religious leaders)

Power

Ability to influence decisions or control resources

Gender

Patriarchal societies privilege males

Ethnicity

Ethnic majorities often dominate

Religion

Religious affiliation affects access to opportunities

Education

Formal degrees stratify people into qualified vs. unqualified

Occupation

Some jobs carry more prestige and income

  1. Determinants of Social Stratification in Pakistani Society
  2. Feudal and Tribal Heritage
  • Rural Pakistan remains feudal, where landlords control land, resources, and people.
  • In provinces like Sindh, Balochistan, and Punjab, stratification is tied to landholding families and tribal hierarchies.
  • Political power is often inherited, not earned.

Over 50% of Pakistan’s parliamentarians belong to landholding families (PILDAT, 2022).

  1. Educational Disparities
  • Access to quality education is deeply stratified:
    • Elite: English-medium private schools
    • Middle class: Government schools
    • Poor: Madaris or illiteracy
  • Stratification in education leads to stratified job markets and income inequality.
  1. Economic Inequality and Class Structure
  • Top 10% of households own over 60% of wealth (UNDP Report, 2021).
  • The rise of urban elite, salaried class, and working poor reflects economic stratification.
  1. Gender-Based Stratification
  • Patriarchy restricts women’s mobility, education, employment.
  • Women make up only 22% of the formal workforce.
  • Honor culture (e.g., karo-kari) further marginalizes women.
  1. Religious and Sectarian Identity
  • Minority communities (e.g., Ahmadis, Hindus, Christians) often face discrimination.
  • Access to jobs, political representation, and safety is unequal.
  1. Caste-like Stratification (Biradari System)
  • Though Islam discourages caste, South Asian cultural traditions persist.
  • Castes like Arain, Rajput, Jatt, Syed influence marriage, politics, and social acceptance.
  • Kammi castes (e.g., barbers, sweepers) face exclusion and stigma.
  1. Urban-Rural Divide
  • Urban areas have better infrastructure, jobs, and education.
  • Rural dwellers often lack basic amenities, reinforcing inequality.
  1. Impacts of Stratification on Pakistani Society

Domain

Impact

Education

Unequal access to quality education across classes

Politics

Elitist political capture; dynastic rule

Economy

Concentration of wealth; poor upward mobility

Gender

Subjugation of women; low participation

Social Harmony

Rising resentment, crime, and radicalization

Justice

Unequal treatment before law (e.g., VIP culture)

“Inequality in society is the root of social unrest.” – Thomas Piketty

  1. Critical Analysis: Functional or Disruptive?

Functionalists argue:

  • Stratification motivates people to aspire and perform.
  • Provides social order.

Critics (e.g., Marxists) argue:

  • It is exploitative, preserving privileges for elites.
  • Reinforces status quo, blocks mobility, and breeds resentment.

In Pakistan:

  • Stratification often leads to conflict, as seen in ethnic violence, sectarian attacks, and class-based unrest.
  • The system fails to reward merit, resulting in brain drain and social alienation.
  1. Conclusion

Social stratification is an inevitable outcome of social complexity, resource scarcity, and role differentiation. However, its nature and extent vary by society.

In Pakistan, stratification is shaped by historical feudalism, education gaps, patriarchy, class structure, and ethno-religious identity. While some degree of stratification is functional, its entrenchment and rigidity threaten social mobility and justice.

To transform stratification into a productive framework rather than a repressive hierarchy, Pakistan must promote:

  • Meritocracy
  • Educational equity
  • Land and legal reforms
  • Gender empowerment
  • Social inclusion of marginalized groups

Q. No. 4: Culture is the essence of the worthwhile, but there is a clear menace to the very soul of the citizen when culture becomes a tool in the hands of the regime of the day with which to transform the outlook of the citizen. Comment.

Outline

  1. Introduction
  2. Defining Culture and Its Significance
  3. Culture as the Soul of Civilization
  4. Culture and the State: A Double-Edged Relationship
  5. Mechanisms Through Which Regimes Shape Culture
    • Media Control
    • Education System
    • Language Policy
    • Religious Narratives
    • National History and Hero Creation
  6. The Manipulation of Culture in Authoritarian and Democratic Regimes
    • Case Study: Nazi Germany
    • Case Study: Soviet Union
    • Case Study: Pakistan (Zia era, etc.)
  7. Sociological Theories Relevant to Cultural Manipulation
    • Gramsci’s Cultural Hegemony
    • Althusser’s Ideological State Apparatuses
    • Durkheim’s Collective Consciousness
    • Marxist View of Superstructure
  8. Implications on the Citizen
    • Loss of Individual Agency
    • Suppression of Diversity and Dissent
    • Rise of Cult of Personality
    • Manufactured Consent
  9. Critical Analysis: Is All Cultural Regulation Dangerous?
  10. Contemporary Relevance: Media and Digital Culture Warfare
  11. Conclusion
  12. References
  1. Introduction

Culture is more than heritage—it is the living ethos that connects individuals to their society’s values, beliefs, art, traditions, and identity. It is the “essence of the worthwhile,” defining how people perceive truth, beauty, justice, and belonging. However, when culture becomes a political tool, its organic role is subverted, and it transforms from a source of identity into an instrument of indoctrination.

This essay explores how regimes manipulate culture to control the minds and souls of citizens, drawing on sociological theory, historical examples, and contemporary relevance.

  1. Defining Culture and Its Significance

Culture refers to the shared practices, symbols, languages, norms, and values of a society. It encompasses:

  • Material culture (artifacts, clothes, food)
  • Non-material culture (ideas, ideologies, language, rituals)

“Culture is the way of life of a people—their design for living.” — Clyde Kluckhohn

Culture is transmitted through socialization, shaping identity, behavior, and worldviews. It provides meaning, moral compass, and a sense of belonging.

  1. Culture as the Soul of Civilization
  • Culture preserves collective memory and ensures intergenerational continuity.
  • It enables social cohesion and guides citizens through values and traditions.
  • UNESCO affirms cultural rights as part of fundamental human rights.
  1. Culture and the State: A Double-Edged Relationship

States often claim to be custodians of national culture, promoting:

  • National holidays
  • State languages
  • Traditional values

However, this cultural stewardship often veers into manipulation, particularly when regimes seek to:

  • Legitimize authority
  • Suppress dissent
  • Create ideological conformity
  1. Mechanisms Through Which Regimes Shape Culture
  2. Media Control

State-run or state-influenced media filters cultural production, promotes propaganda, and suppresses critical voices.

  1. Education System

Textbooks and curricula are designed to instill loyalty, sanitize history, and glorify national figures.

In Pakistan, curriculum revision under General Zia emphasized Islamic identity and nationalism over pluralism.

  1. Language Policy

Language is used to unify or exclude. Imposing a national language (e.g., Urdu in East Pakistan) can lead to cultural erasure.

  1. Religious Narratives

Religious discourse is manipulated to legitimize regime actions, often leading to the weaponization of faith.

  1. National History and Hero Creation

Selective glorification of heroes and past events fosters a singular narrative, leaving no space for alternative interpretations.

  1. Manipulation of Culture in Authoritarian and Democratic Regimes
  2. Nazi Germany
  • Hitler used film, music, art, education, and mythology to glorify Aryan supremacy.
  • The regime demonized Jews culturally before persecuting them physically.
  1. Soviet Union
  • Stalin’s socialist realism promoted idealized workers and obedience.
  • Dissenting cultural expressions were banned or labeled as “bourgeois”.
  1. Pakistan
  • Under General Zia-ul-Haq (1977–1988), state-imposed Islamization policies redefined cultural norms.
  • Film, TV, and literature had to conform to state-defined moral codes.
  • Women’s roles were confined to “honor-bearers” of Islamic values.
  1. Sociological Theories Relevant to Cultural Manipulation
  2. Antonio Gramsci – Cultural Hegemony

The ruling class maintains control not through force alone but by shaping cultural norms so that their ideology becomes “common sense.”

“The most potent weapon in the hands of the oppressor is the mind of the oppressed.” — Gramsci

  1. Louis Althusser – Ideological State Apparatus

Schools, media, and religion act as ISA (Ideological State Apparatuses) that shape citizens’ consciousness, making them comply without coercion.

  1. Emile Durkheim – Collective Consciousness

While shared culture creates solidarity, over-homogenization can stifle creativity and pluralism.

  1. Karl Marx – Culture as Superstructure

Culture reflects the interests of the ruling class, and controlling culture helps maintain the economic base.

  1. Implications on the Citizen
  2. Loss of Individual Agency

Citizens are discouraged from independent thought; conformity is rewarded, and dissent punished.

  1. Suppression of Diversity

Minorities and alternative cultures are seen as threats rather than contributors to society.

  1. Cult of Personality

Leaders are turned into symbols of national identity, discouraging criticism.

  1. Manufactured Consent

Citizens accept their condition as natural or righteous, as theorized by Noam Chomsky.

  1. Critical Analysis: Is All Cultural Regulation Dangerous?

Not necessarily.

  1. Positive Aspects:
  • Promoting unity, peace, and civic identity
  • Preserving endangered cultural practices
  • Combating hate speech and disinformation
  1. Dangerous When:
  • Culture is used to justify oppression
  • Erases cultural plurality
  • Normalizes false historical narratives

Thus, the intention and method of cultural regulation determine its ethicality.

  1. Contemporary Relevance: Media and Digital Culture Warfare
  • Regimes now use algorithms, social media bots, and misinformation to shape public culture.
  • Digital spaces are flooded with nationalistic or religious propaganda.
  • In Pakistan, cultural control extends to TikTok bans, censorship of dramas, and selective social media blocking.
  1. Conclusion

Culture, in its essence, is a mirror of human spirit, creativity, and collective memory. When left to flourish freely, it empowers societies. However, when culture becomes an extension of state apparatus, it ceases to reflect society and begins to reshape it into ideological obedience.

The menace lies not in promoting cultural identity but in weaponizing culture to engineer citizen behavior, erasing diversity, silencing critical thought, and creating generations disconnected from historical truth and moral agency.

“Art, literature, and culture are not only expressions of society but are the society itself. To control them is to control the soul.” — Edward Said

Q. No. 5: Youth is an Asset of Any Nation but Pakistani Youth is Inclined Towards Youth Bulge. What Strategies Being an Expert Suggests the State to Put the Youth on Positive Track? Give Your Suggestions in the Light of Sociological Theories.

Outline

  1. Introduction
  2. Defining Youth and Youth Bulge
  3. Pakistan’s Demographic Profile and Youth Crisis
  4. Causes Behind Youth Deviation and Disengagement
  5. Theoretical Frameworks to Understand Youth Bulge
    • Functionalist Theory
    • Conflict Theory
    • Strain Theory (Merton)
    • Subculture Theory
    • Labeling Theory
  6. Risks of an Unmanaged Youth Bulge
  7. State-Level Strategies to Positively Channel Youth Energy
    • Education Reforms
    • Employment Generation and Skill Development
    • Civic Engagement and Political Inclusion
    • Sports and Arts Promotion
    • Mental Health and Counseling Infrastructure
    • Digital Literacy and Social Media Regulation
  8. Sociological Justification for Suggested Strategies
  9. Case Studies: Comparative Global Experiences
  10. Critical Analysis
  11. Conclusion
  12. References
  1. Introduction

Youth are often described as the torchbearers of the future, the engine of national progress. However, when a large youth population—termed a “youth bulge”—is poorly educated, unemployed, and disenfranchised, it can become a threat rather than a boon.

Pakistan, with over 64% of its population under 30 (UNDP, 2021), is facing precisely this challenge. This essay explains the phenomenon of youth bulge, analyzes it through sociological theories, and proposes strategies to transform Pakistani youth into a productive force.

  1. Defining Youth and Youth Bulge
  • Youth: According to UN, individuals aged 15 to 24, while Pakistan often considers 15 to 29 years as youth.
  • Youth Bulge: A demographic pattern where a large proportion of a country’s population is composed of youth, often the result of declining infant mortality and high birth rates.

“Youth bulge can either be a time bomb or a demographic dividend.” — David Bloom

  1. Pakistan’s Demographic Profile and Youth Crisis

Category

Statistic

Youth population

~135 million (64% under 30)

Youth unemployment

8.5% (official), 25–30% (underemployment)

Literacy rate (15–24)

71% (gender-disaggregated gap: 15%)

Access to higher education

<10%

Challenges:

  • Joblessness
  • Radicalization
  • Drug abuse
  • Disillusionment
  • Brain drain
  1. Causes Behind Youth Deviation and Disengagement
  • Educational system mismatch with job market
  • Nepotism and corruption limiting fair access
  • Lack of counseling and life-skills training
  • Poor mental health support
  • Absence of civic and political representation
  • Prevalence of digital misinformation and escapism
  1. Theoretical Frameworks to Understand Youth Bulge
  2. Functionalist Perspective (Durkheim, Parsons)
  • Youth need to be integrated into society through institutions like education, religion, and family.
  • Failure of these institutions leads to anomie (normlessness) and deviant behavior.
  1. Conflict Theory (Karl Marx)
  • Youth marginalization is a result of class struggle.
  • Elite capture of resources leads to frustration and rebellion.
  1. Strain Theory (Robert Merton)
  • When societal goals (e.g., success) are not accessible due to lack of means (e.g., jobs, education), youth resort to deviance.
  1. Subculture Theory
  • Alienated youth form subcultures (e.g., drug gangs, online extremist groups) with values opposed to mainstream norms.
  1. Labeling Theory (Howard Becker)
  • When youth are labeled as idle or violent, they may internalize and live up to those labels—a self-fulfilling prophecy.
  1. Risks of an Unmanaged Youth Bulge
  • Radicalization and Extremism (as seen in recruitment by sectarian and terrorist groups)
  • Brain Drain (high-skilled migration due to lack of opportunity)
  • Social unrest and crime
  • Increased burden on welfare systems
  • Weakening of democratic institutions as youth become apathetic or disillusioned
  1. State-Level Strategies to Positively Channel Youth Energy
  2. Education Reforms
  • Align curriculum with 21st-century skills (critical thinking, IT, problem-solving).
  • Introduce career counseling from school level.
  • Promote TVET (Technical and Vocational Education and Training).

“An educated, skilled youth is a state’s best armor and architect.” — Amartya Sen

  1. Employment Generation and Entrepreneurship
  • Encourage start-ups through seed funding and microfinance.
  • Incentivize the private sector to hire young people via tax breaks.
  • Strengthen freelancing and remote work infrastructure.
  1. Civic Engagement and Political Inclusion
  • Lower voting age awareness campaigns
  • Youth quotas in local bodies and political parties
  • Establish youth parliaments and participation in policy-making
  1. Sports and Arts Promotion
  • Build community sports complexes, youth clubs, and creative spaces.
  • Support film, music, drama, and literature initiatives to provide outlets for expression and identity building.
  1. Mental Health and Counseling Infrastructure
  • Establish mental health cells in schools/universities.
  • Train youth in emotional intelligence, stress management.
  1. Digital Literacy and Social Media Regulation
  • Train youth to discern fake news, online scams, and hate speech.
  • Promote cyberethics and safe digital spaces.
  1. Sociological Justification for Suggested Strategies

Strategy

Sociological Link

Education reform

Parsons: Schools as agents of social integration

Employment programs

Merton’s strain theory: Reduce illegitimate means

Civic inclusion

Durkheim: Increase social cohesion and belonging

Sports/art

Subculture theory: Offer constructive identities

Mental health

Becker: Prevent internalization of deviant labels

Digital literacy

Gramsci: Resist ideological hegemony through awareness

  1. Case Studies: Comparative Global Experiences

Rwanda

  • Youth inclusion policies post-genocide led to massive entrepreneurship growth.
  • National Youth Councils were empowered legally.

Malaysia

  • Youth Skills Training Program (YSTP) successfully transitioned rural youth into formal economy.

India

  • Startup India initiative fostered youth-led innovations; over 100,000 startups registered since 2016.

Pakistan

  • Kamyab Jawan Program shows potential but lacks transparency, scalability, and institutional backing.
  1. Critical Analysis

While the youth bulge offers great promise, it can also lead to instability if not managed properly. Pakistani policymakers must stop viewing youth as passive recipients and treat them as active stakeholders.

However, mere slogans or temporary schemes will not work without:

  • Structural reforms in education and governance
  • Consistent implementation
  • Youth-led monitoring and accountability

Furthermore, culture and religion should not be weaponized to restrict the youth, but rather used to inspire social responsibility and innovation.

  1. Conclusion

Pakistan’s youth are not its liability—they are its untapped goldmine. But if left jobless, voiceless, and visionless, they may become the drivers of social instability rather than prosperity.

Through a combination of education, empowerment, and engagement, guided by sociological insight, the state can transform its youth bulge into a demographic dividend.

“If we do not build a future for our youth, they will destroy the one we have.” — Franklin D. Roosevelt (paraphrased)

Q. No. 6: Describe the Major Work of Robert King Merton in Sociology. Explain His Work with Suitable Examples.

Outline

  1. Introduction
  2. Biography and Intellectual Background
  3. Merton’s Key Contributions to Sociology
    • Middle-Range Theory
    • Manifest and Latent Functions
    • Reference Group Theory
    • Role-Set Theory
    • Anomie and Strain Theory
  4. Merton’s Work in the Sociology of Science
    • Ethos of Science
    • Matthew Effect
  5. Examples of Merton’s Theories in Contemporary Context
    • Crime and Deviance
    • Social Media Behavior
    • Educational Aspirations
  6. Comparison with Other Sociologists
    • Merton vs. Durkheim
    • Merton vs. Parsons
  7. Critical Evaluation
  8. Relevance of Merton’s Work in Today’s World
  9. Conclusion
  10. References
  1. Introduction

Robert King Merton (1910–2003) is hailed as one of the founding figures of modern American sociology, renowned for his efforts to bridge the gap between grand theory and empirical research. Merton’s genius lay in his ability to develop concepts that were applicable, testable, and explanatory in real-world settings, without losing sight of the broader theoretical landscape.

His contributions span a variety of sociological fields, from the sociology of deviance to the sociology of science, and continue to shape sociological thinking and research.

  1. Biography and Intellectual Background
  • Born Meyer Schkolnick to a poor immigrant family in Philadelphia, Merton studied under Pitirim Sorokin and Talcott Parsons at Harvard.
  • He taught at Columbia University, where he mentored generations of sociologists.
  • He emphasized empirical research, functional analysis, and scientific integrity.

“Robert Merton gave sociology its scientific spine.” — Anthony Giddens

  1. Merton’s Key Contributions to Sociology
  2. Middle-Range Theory

Definition: Theories that lie between grand abstract frameworks (e.g., Marxism or functionalism) and narrow empirical observations.

  • Middle-range theories are specific enough to be tested but general enough to apply across contexts.
  • Examples include theories of role conflict, deviance, and bureaucracy.

“Middle-range theory is the engine room of sociology.” — Merton

  1. Manifest and Latent Functions

In his 1949 classic Social Theory and Social Structure, Merton introduced the dual-functionality of social practices.

  • Manifest functions: Intended and recognized (e.g., education teaches skills).
  • Latent functions: Unintended and hidden (e.g., education delays entry into labor market or reinforces class stratification).

Example:

  • Manifest function of religious gatherings: worship and spiritual bonding.
  • Latent function: reinforce group solidarity or even exclusion of others.

This concept is crucial for policy analysis and institutional evaluation.

  1. Reference Group Theory

People evaluate themselves based on comparison with others in groups they aspire to join or identify with.

  • Helps explain social mobility, self-esteem, and group behavior.
  • Example: A middle-class student might adopt behaviors of the elite class due to aspirations, even without access to their resources.
  1. Role-Set Theory

Each social status involves a “role set”—a collection of expectations from different groups.

  • Unlike Parsons, who assumed harmonious role performance, Merton acknowledged role strain, where fulfilling one role may conflict with others.

Example:

  • A doctor has to treat patients (ethical role), satisfy hospital administrators (economic role), and fulfill teaching duties—all of which can conflict.
  1. Anomie and Strain Theory (1938)

Expanding on Durkheim’s concept of anomie, Merton proposed that societal structures can pressure individuals into deviance when legitimate means are unavailable.

Five modes of adaptation:

Mode

Cultural Goals

Institutional Means

Example

Conformity

Accept

Accept

Most people

Innovation

Accept

Reject

Criminals (e.g., fraudsters)

Ritualism

Reject

Accept

Bureaucrats

Retreatism

Reject

Reject

Addicts, vagrants

Rebellion

New goals

New means

Revolutionaries, activists

Example in Pakistan:

  • Unemployed youth might innovate by entering drug trade.
  • Overburdened civil servants may become ritualistic.
  1. Merton’s Work in the Sociology of Science
  2. Ethos of Science (1942)

Merton proposed four normative principles governing scientific conduct:

  1. Communalism: Knowledge should be shared.
  2. Universalism: Science judged by quality, not by who presents it.
  3. Disinterestedness: Scientists should not seek personal gain.
  4. Organized Skepticism: All claims must be tested and verified.

This framework still guides ethical norms in research today.

  1. Matthew Effect

Coined in 1968, the Matthew Effect explains why famous scientists receive more recognition than lesser-known peers for similar work.

“For unto every one that hath shall be given…” — Gospel of Matthew

Example: Senior researchers receive awards even if junior collaborators did much of the work.

  1. Examples of Merton’s Theories in Contemporary Context
  2. Crime and Deviance
  • Merton’s strain theory explains rising crimes among unemployed urban youth who are bombarded with consumerist values but lack access to legitimate means.
  1. Social Media and Reference Groups
  • Youth on Instagram and TikTok often experience anxiety due to unrealistic comparison with influencers (reference group theory).
  • Latent function of social media: perpetuates consumerist values and body-image issues.
  1. Education and Role Strain
  • Teachers face conflicting roles: educators, disciplinarians, examiners, and caregivers.
  1. Comparison with Other Sociologists

Merton vs. Durkheim

  • Both studied anomie, but Merton focused on individual adaptations while Durkheim emphasized macro-level regulation.

Merton vs. Parsons

  • While Parsons promoted grand systemic theory, Merton believed in testable middle-range theories.
  • Parsons viewed roles as harmonious, Merton emphasized role conflict and strain.
  1. Critical Evaluation

Strengths

  • Empirical applicability: Concepts like latent function and strain theory are widely used in criminology, education, and policy analysis.
  • Balanced approach between theory and data.
  • Foundation for modern functionalism.

Limitations

  • Critics argue strain theory overemphasizes economic success.
  • Neglects the role of emotions and identity in deviance.
  • His analysis of science is idealistic—ignores institutional politics and corporate interests.
  1. Relevance of Merton’s Work in Today’s World

Merton’s theories are remarkably prescient:

  • COVID-19 pandemic: Reference groups and role strain among healthcare workers.
  • Rise in online fraud: Innovation as a deviant mode.
  • Post-truth era: Challenge to Merton’s ethos of science.
  • Youth radicalization: Explains retreatism and rebellion adaptations.
  1. Conclusion

Robert K. Merton stands out as a sociologist who married abstract theory with real-world relevance. His frameworks—especially strain theory, latent functions, and middle-range theory—equip us with tools to interpret the complex, layered realities of contemporary society.

In an age of social disruption, institutional strain, and information overload, Merton’s insights offer clarity, structure, and guidance, proving their continued relevance.

“Merton did not just explain society—he gave us a vocabulary to talk about it.” — Craig Calhoun

Q. No. 7: Which Types of Research by Objective Are Commonly Being Used by NGOs and Explain These Types of Research with Suitable Examples?

Outline

  1. Introduction
  2. Role of NGOs in Research and Policy
  3. Classification of Research by Objective
  4. Common Types of Research by Objective Used by NGOs
    • Exploratory Research
    • Descriptive Research
    • Explanatory (Causal) Research
    • Evaluative (Assessment) Research
    • Action Research
    • Policy-Oriented Research
  5. Examples of Research in Pakistani NGO Sector
  6. Relevance and Applications in Real-World Problems
  7. Critical Evaluation
  8. Challenges Faced by NGOs in Conducting Research
  9. Recommendations for Improving NGO Research Capacity
  10. Conclusion
  11. References
  1. Introduction

Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) serve as vital agents of social change, community development, human rights advocacy, and policy influence. One of the key tools they use for impact is research—to understand issues, mobilize data, and shape interventions. Unlike purely academic institutions, NGOs conduct pragmatic, goal-oriented, and time-sensitive research, often classified by objectives that serve their programs and missions.

“NGOs conduct research not to theorize, but to transform.” — Dr. Ayesha Jalal

  1. Role of NGOs in Research and Policy

NGOs in Pakistan like Aurat Foundation, Edhi Foundation, Akhuwat, The Citizens Foundation (TCF), and SPO often undertake studies related to poverty alleviation, women’s rights, education, and disaster response.

Their research plays a role in:

  • Evidence-based policy advocacy
  • Program monitoring and evaluation
  • Community engagement strategies
  • Awareness and sensitization campaigns
  1. Classification of Research by Objective

Sociological research, when classified by objective, typically falls into:

Type

Purpose

Example

Exploratory

To explore a new issue or problem

Gender-based violence in tribal areas

Descriptive

To describe characteristics or trends

Literacy rates in urban slums

Explanatory

To explain cause-effect relationships

Poverty and school dropout correlation

Evaluative

To assess impact of interventions

NGO-led microcredit programs

Action

To produce immediate change

Hygiene campaigns in flood zones

Policy-oriented

To propose or revise public policies

Legal reforms for street children

  1. Common Types of Research by Objective Used by NGOs
  2. Exploratory Research

Objective: Investigate poorly understood phenomena or new problems.

  • Use by NGOs: When entering a new geographic area or issue domain.
  • Example:
    An NGO exploring gender-based violence in remote Balochistan may conduct focus groups to understand cultural barriers before designing interventions.
  • Methods: Interviews, pilot surveys, ethnography.
  1. Descriptive Research

Objective: Present a detailed account of current conditions, attitudes, or events.

  • Use by NGOs: Baseline studies or needs assessments.
  • Example:
    The Citizens Foundation (TCF) conducts descriptive surveys to profile student enrollment, dropout rates, and family backgrounds before opening new campuses.
  • Methods: Structured questionnaires, census mapping, statistical summaries.
  1. Explanatory (Causal) Research

Objective: Explain why a phenomenon occurs by identifying cause-and-effect relationships.

  • Use by NGOs: To inform advocacy or modify strategy.
  • Example:
    An NGO working on child malnutrition may study whether maternal illiteracy and low income directly impact stunting rates in rural Sindh.
  • Methods: Regression analysis, hypothesis testing.
  1. Evaluative (Assessment) Research

Objective: Assess effectiveness or impact of programs or policies.

  • Use by NGOs: Regularly conducted as mid-term or end-of-project evaluations.
  • Example:
    Akhuwat may evaluate whether its interest-free microloans significantly increased women’s income and social empowerment in southern Punjab.
  • Methods: Randomized control trials (RCTs), pre/post comparisons, stakeholder interviews.
  1. Action Research

Objective: Immediate problem-solving through community participation and localized intervention.

  • Use by NGOs: Rural development, health campaigns, disaster management.
  • Example:
    During the 2022 floods, NGOs conducted real-time data collection to improve relief delivery in Dadu, Sindh.
  • Methods: Participatory rural appraisal (PRA), community mapping.

“Action research is research by the people, for the people.” — Kurt Lewin

  1. Policy-Oriented Research

Objective: Influence government or institutional policy through recommendations based on research.

  • Use by NGOs: Advocacy organizations.
  • Example:
    Aurat Foundation conducted policy research to push for anti-harassment legislation, using victim testimony and national data.
  • Methods: White papers, policy briefs, legal analysis.
  1. Examples of Research in Pakistani NGO Sector

NGO

Research Objective Type

Project Example

Aurat Foundation

Policy-oriented, descriptive

Gender equality & legal reforms

Akhuwat

Evaluative

Impact of interest-free loans on poverty

The Citizens Foundation

Descriptive, explanatory

Learning outcomes of students in low-income neighborhoods

Saylani Trust

Exploratory, action

Needs assessment during COVID-19 lockdown

SPO (Strengthening Participatory Org.)

Action, evaluative

Community mobilization for polio eradication

  1. Relevance and Applications in Real-World Problems

NGOs use research to address problems such as:

  • Health Inequity: Evaluative research on maternal mortality in interior Sindh.
  • Education Gaps: Descriptive surveys on missing facilities in rural schools.
  • Gender Inequality: Exploratory and policy research to push for domestic violence laws.
  • Food Security: Action research to build kitchen gardens in flood-hit areas.
  1. Critical Evaluation

Strengths:

  • Grounded in real issues, not abstract theories.
  • Flexible and participatory, incorporating voices of marginalized groups.
  • Often leads to direct social impact and policy change.

Weaknesses:

  • Lack of rigor and peer review compared to academic research.
  • Donor-driven bias may influence objectivity.
  • Limited capacity for longitudinal studies or large-scale random sampling.
  1. Challenges Faced by NGOs in Conducting Research
  1. Funding constraints: Research is often not prioritized in donor budgets.
  2. Limited expertise: NGOs may lack trained sociologists or statisticians.
  3. Data inaccessibility: Government data is often outdated or unavailable.
  4. Community resistance: Especially in conservative or tribal regions.
  5. Ethical concerns: Protection of vulnerable populations in fieldwork.
  1. Recommendations for Improving NGO Research Capacity
  • Collaboration with universities and think tanks (e.g., PIDE, SDPI)
  • Establish independent research departments
  • Use mixed-methods approach to balance data richness and generalizability
  • Train staff in SPSS, NVivo, GIS, and other research tools
  • Advocate for open data platforms for civil society
  • Create ethics boards for community-focused research
  1. Conclusion

NGOs in Pakistan and globally have evolved into critical research actors, especially in settings where state capacity is weak or bureaucratically slow. Their ability to use research that is goal-oriented, context-sensitive, and participatory enables them to effectively advocate, intervene, and innovate.

By strategically using exploratory, descriptive, evaluative, and policy-oriented research, NGOs act as both mirrors and catalysts for society—identifying its problems, informing its solutions, and shaping its future.

Q8 Short Notes:-

  1. a) Law of Three Stages by Auguste Comte

Introduction
Auguste Comte (1798–1857), known as the “Father of Sociology,” developed the Law of Three Stages to explain the intellectual evolution of human society. According to Comte, human thought progresses through three sequential stages: Theological, Metaphysical, and Positive (Scientific).

  1. Theological Stage (Fictitious Stage)
  • Dominated by supernatural beliefs.
  • Phenomena are explained through divine or spiritual forces.
  • Divided into sub-stages:
    • Animism: Spirits in nature (tribal societies).
    • Polytheism: Multiple gods (ancient Greeks, Hindus).
    • Monotheism: One supreme god (Abrahamic faiths).

Example: Disease was explained as punishment by gods.

  1. Metaphysical Stage (Abstract Stage)
  • Abstract philosophical explanations replaced divine ones.
  • Personified abstract forces such as nature or destiny were invoked.
  • Society began questioning the “why” instead of “who.”

Example: Instead of divine punishment, illness was attributed to “imbalance in bodily humors” or “nature’s will.”

  1. Positive Stage (Scientific Stage)
  • Relies on empirical observation, logic, and experimentation.
  • Search for invariable laws of society, just like natural sciences.
  • Birth of sociology as a scientific discipline.

Example: Disease is studied through germs, pathogens, and medicine.

Critical Appraisal

  • Comte’s theory was evolutionary, implying linear progress from ignorance to knowledge.
  • Critics argue that societies can coexist at different stages simultaneously (e.g., Pakistan’s blend of religious, philosophical, and scientific explanations).

“Sociology is the queen of the sciences.” — Auguste Comte

(b) Suicide by Emile Durkheim

Introduction
Émile Durkheim (1858–1917), a pioneer of sociology, conducted one of the first scientific studies of a social phenomenon in his book Le Suicide (1897). He argued that suicide is not just an individual act, but deeply rooted in social factors.

Durkheim’s Types of Suicide

  1. Egoistic Suicide
  • Caused by low social integration.
  • Individuals feel isolated, disconnected.
  • Common in societies with weak family ties or individualism.
    Example: Higher suicide rates among elderly living alone.
  1. Altruistic Suicide
  • Due to excessive integration.
  • Individuals sacrifice themselves for the group.
    Example: Kamikaze pilots, religious extremists, or ritual suicides.
  1. Anomic Suicide
  • Triggered by low social regulation.
  • Happens during periods of sudden change or economic crisis.
    Example: Suicides during the Great Depression or after sudden unemployment.
  1. Fatalistic Suicide
  • Results from excessive regulation.
  • Individual sees no escape from oppression.
    Example: Slaves, prisoners, or individuals in extremely repressive settings.

Methodology and Legacy

  • Durkheim used comparative statistics from different countries and religious groups.
  • Found that Protestants had higher suicide rates than Catholics due to weaker social integration.

Significance

  • Marked the birth of empirical sociology.
  • Showed that social forces shape individual behavior.

“The more strongly integrated the social groups to which he belongs, the less likely he is to commit suicide.” — Émile Durkheim

. . Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 Sociology 2016 

You cannot copy content of this pages.