Q. No. 2. What is the difference between crime, deviance, sin and vice? Do you believe that crime is one of the major social problems of Pakistani society? Discuss.
Outline:
- Introduction
- Definitions and Key Differences
- Crime
- Deviance
- Sin
- Vice
- Comparative Table
- Crime as a Major Social Problem in Pakistan
- Causes of Crime in Pakistani Society
- Impacts of Crime on Society
- Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
Human behavior is governed by laws, moral codes, and social norms. When individuals violate these, they may commit a crime, deviant act, sin, or vice—each with unique consequences and meanings. In Pakistani society, crime has emerged as a pressing issue, affecting public safety, social trust, and national stability.
- Definitions and Key Differences
✅ Crime
A crime is an act that violates written laws and is punishable by the state.
Examples: murder, theft, fraud, drug trafficking
Punishment: imprisonment, fines, execution (in severe cases)
✅ Deviance
Deviance refers to behavior that violates social or cultural norms, but may not be illegal.
Examples: body piercings, breaking dress codes, living together without marriage
Punishment: social sanctions, stigma, exclusion
✅ Sin
A sin is a violation of divine or religious commandments as prescribed by scriptures.
Examples: lying, adultery, drinking alcohol (in Islam)
Punishment: moral guilt, religious consequences, or divine judgment (hereafter)
✅ Vice
A vice is a habit or practice considered morally bad or depraved, often repetitive.
Examples: gambling, substance abuse, promiscuity
Punishment: social disapproval, in some cases legal penalty (if law criminalizes the act)
- Comparative Table
Concept | Source of Rule | Type of Violation | Punishment Type |
Crime | State Law | Legal | Formal (arrest, court) |
Deviance | Social Norms | Cultural/Social | Informal (shame, exclusion) |
Sin | Religion (Divine Law) | Spiritual/Religious | Moral/Religious |
Vice | Moral Philosophy | Ethical/Moral | Informal or legal |
- Is Crime a Major Social Problem in Pakistan?
✅ Yes, crime is one of the most serious social issues in Pakistan today, due to its:
- High visibility
- Impact on safety, economy, and governance
- Association with poverty, corruption, and weak institutions
- Causes of Crime in Pakistan
Category | Examples |
Economic | Unemployment, inflation, poverty, income inequality |
Social | Illiteracy, urban overcrowding, drug addiction |
Political | Weak governance, corruption, politicization of police |
Legal | Delayed justice, low conviction rates, poor investigation |
Technological | Cybercrime, online scams, identity theft |
- Impacts of Crime on Society
- 😨 Fear and insecurity in daily life
- 📉 Decline in investment and tourism
- ⚖️ Burden on courts and police
- 🤝 Erosion of social trust
- 👎 Weakens rule of law and governance
- Recommendations
- 👮♂️ Police reforms: merit-based recruitment, tech training, community policing
- ⚖️ Speedy justice: special courts for street crime and white-collar cases
- 💼 Employment generation for youth to prevent economic-driven crime
- 📚 Education and moral development in schools
- 🌐 Cybercrime laws and surveillance to tackle digital threats
- 🤝 Engage religious leaders to address sin- and vice-related behaviors
- Conclusion
Crime, deviance, sin, and vice are interlinked yet distinct categories that regulate human behavior in legal, social, moral, and religious domains. In Pakistan, crime has escalated into a major social crisis, fueled by structural inequalities, governance deficits, and moral decay. A holistic response involving law enforcement, education, religious reform, and community engagement is urgently needed to address this menace.
“Where justice fails, crime rises; and where society fails, criminals flourish.”
Q. No. 3. What is the meaning of Anomie? Discuss Robert Merton theory of Anomie in detail.
Outline:
- Introduction
- Meaning of Anomie
- Origin of the Concept (Émile Durkheim)
- Merton’s Contribution: Anomie and Strain Theory
- Five Modes of Individual Adaptation
- Relevance to Crime and Deviance
- Application in the Pakistani Context
- Criticism of Merton’s Theory
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
Anomie, a key concept in sociology and criminology, explains how breakdown of social norms and mismatch between goals and means lead to deviant behavior. Robert K. Merton, building upon Émile Durkheim’s work, introduced a structured theory of Anomie to explain why people commit crimes in unequal societies.
- Meaning of Anomie
Anomie refers to a state of normlessness, confusion, or instability in society where traditional norms and values collapse.
This disintegration leads individuals to feel disconnected, directionless, and more likely to engage in deviance or crime.
- Durkheim’s Original Concept
- Coined by Émile Durkheim in his study of suicide (1897)
- Linked high suicide rates to rapid social change and lack of moral regulation
- Anomie = absence of clear norms during societal upheaval
- Robert Merton’s Theory of Anomie (Strain Theory)
Merton redefined anomie in the American context where society places strong emphasis on cultural goals (e.g., wealth, success) but offers unequal access to legitimate means (e.g., education, employment).
Anomie arises when individuals cannot achieve culturally approved goals through socially approved means, resulting in strain.
- Merton’s Five Modes of Individual Adaptation
Adaptation | Cultural Goals | Institutional Means | Explanation |
1. Conformity | Accept | Accept | Follows rules to achieve goals (most people) |
2. Innovation | Accept | Reject | Uses illegal means (e.g., thieves, fraudsters) |
3. Ritualism | Reject | Accept | Follows rules but gives up on success (e.g., routine clerks) |
4. Retreatism | Reject | Reject | Withdraws from society (e.g., drug addicts, homeless) |
5. Rebellion | New goals | New means | Seeks to replace both goals and means (e.g., revolutionaries) |
🔺 Innovation is most linked to criminal behavior.
- Relevance to Crime and Deviance
- Merton explains that criminals are not abnormal, but are reacting logically to blocked opportunities
- Explains rise of crimes like fraud, smuggling, corruption, terrorism in societies with inequality and class barriers
- Application in the Pakistani Context
- 🇵🇰 Widespread poverty and unemployment lead youth toward crime
- 💼 Corruption seen as a “shortcut” to success when legal paths are blocked
- 🎓 Graduates unable to find jobs despite degrees → strain → deviance
- 💣 Radical groups exploit strain by offering alternative means/goals (rebellion)
- Criticism of Merton’s Theory
- ❌ Overemphasis on material success (ignores non-economic motivations for crime)
- 📉 Does not explain why only some people under strain turn to crime
- 🌐 Lacks consideration of cultural and gender differences
- 🔍 Ignores crimes of passion or mental illness (non-goal-oriented crimes)
- Conclusion
Merton’s Theory of Anomie is a powerful sociological explanation for deviance in societies marked by inequality, blocked opportunities, and high aspirations. In Pakistan, where a large segment of the population faces economic and social strain, the theory remains highly relevant in understanding white-collar crimes, street offenses, and extremism. However, for a holistic view, it must be supplemented with psychological, cultural, and institutional perspectives.
“When success is a must but means are denied, the road to crime opens wide.” — Adapted from Mertonian Thought
Q. No. 4. Define the term juvenile delinquency. Write a note on the history of juvenile justice system and role of juvenile court in reducing juvenile delinquency.
Outline:
- Introduction
- Definition of Juvenile Delinquency
- Historical Evolution of Juvenile Justice System
- Global Development of Juvenile Courts
- Juvenile Justice System in Pakistan
- Role of Juvenile Courts in Crime Reduction
- Challenges in Juvenile Justice Administration
- Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
Juvenile delinquency is a major concern for all societies, as it involves young offenders engaging in criminal or antisocial behavior. Instead of punishment, modern justice systems emphasize rehabilitation and reintegration for juveniles. Juvenile courts are central institutions in this philosophy, aimed at preventing these youth from becoming habitual offenders.
- Definition of Juvenile Delinquency
Juvenile delinquency refers to criminal or deviant acts committed by individuals under the age of 18, as per the legal definition of a juvenile.
Examples: theft, drug use, gang involvement, violence, vandalism.
- History of Juvenile Justice System
✅ Global History
- 🏛️ Before the 19th century: Juveniles were tried and punished like adults
- 📜 1825 (USA): New York House of Refuge was the first separate facility for juvenile offenders
- ⚖️ 1899 (Chicago, USA): First Juvenile Court established focusing on rehabilitation over punishment
✅ Key Principles Introduced:
- Juveniles need protection, not punishment
- Focus on best interests of the child
- Use of probation, counseling, vocational training
- Juvenile Justice in Pakistan
- Governed by Juvenile Justice System Act (JJSA), 2018
- Ensures:
- Juvenile courts with child-friendly procedures
- Prohibition of death penalty or adult imprisonment for juveniles
- Diversion programs (rehabilitation instead of trial)
- Probation officers, child protection centers, and social reintegration
- Role of Juvenile Courts in Reducing Delinquency
Function | Explanation |
⚖️ Separate Trials | Juveniles are tried in specialized courts with privacy and sensitivity |
🧠 Psychological Evaluation | Courts assess behavior and background before decisions |
📚 Rehabilitation Orders | Direct juveniles toward training centers and counseling programs |
🚫 Avoids Criminal Stigma | Non-custodial measures prevent long-term criminal identity |
🧑🏫 Parental Involvement | Juvenile courts often engage families in behavioral correction |
🔄 Diversion and Probation | Promotes second chances through non-punitive interventions |
- Impact on Reducing Delinquency
- Encourages behavioral reform, not punishment
- Reduces repeat offenses by focusing on root causes (poverty, neglect, peer pressure)
- Builds opportunities for social reintegration and skill development
- Improves child protection standards in line with UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC)
- Challenges in Pakistan
- 🚧 Lack of juvenile courts and trained probation officers in many districts
- 🏚️ Inadequate rehabilitation centers and shelter homes
- 🛑 Police abuse, custodial violence, and unlawful detention of juveniles
- ⚖️ Delays in court trials and weak legal aid
- 📉 Lack of awareness among parents and communities about juvenile rights
- Recommendations
- 👨⚖️ Establish dedicated juvenile benches in all districts
- 🧑🏫 Train police, judges, and prison staff in child rights and juvenile law
- 🏠 Develop shelters, vocational centers, and halfway homes
- 📣 Run awareness campaigns for families, schools, and religious leaders
- 🤝 Encourage NGO and community partnerships for diversion programs
- 📜 Implement JJSA (2018) in letter and spirit
- Conclusion
Juvenile delinquency is best addressed not with retribution, but with understanding, support, and structure. Juvenile courts, when properly resourced and guided by rehabilitative philosophy, can transform young offenders into law-abiding, productive citizens. In Pakistan, where nearly 60% of the population is under 25, a functional and compassionate juvenile justice system is both a moral duty and a national need.
“Children in conflict with law deserve correction—not condemnation.”
Q. No. 5. In Pakistan, the creation of police force is a colonial legacy. In which circumstances independent police force was established in the pre-independence era. What major changes have been occurred in the police department in Pakistan?
Outline:
- Introduction
- British Colonial Legacy and Police Creation
- Circumstances Behind Establishment of Independent Police (Pre-1947)
- Key Features of the Colonial Police System
- Post-Independence Reforms in Pakistan
- Major Structural and Functional Changes
- Challenges to Reform
- Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
The police system in Pakistan is rooted in the British colonial administration, designed not for public service, but for controlling subjects, suppressing dissent, and protecting imperial interests. Despite independence in 1947, the basic architecture of policing remained unchanged. Over the decades, however, multiple reforms have attempted to modernize, democratize, and localize policing in Pakistan.
- Colonial Legacy of Policing
- The British introduced organized policing after the 1857 War of Independence, fearing rebellion
- The Police Act of 1861 was enforced to create a centralized, authoritarian force
- Purpose: maintain law and order, control the native population, and protect colonial rule—not serve or empower citizens
- Circumstances of Independent Police Establishment (Pre-Independence Era)
- After 1857, British administration viewed natives as a threat
- Rejected proposals for local empowerment or community policing
- Created a force:
- Militarized in nature
- Loyal to the crown, not the people
- Headed by District Magistrates and Police Superintendents
- The 1861 Police Act formed the backbone of this new force, modeled after the Irish Constabulary
- Key Features of Colonial Police System
- Highly centralized and hierarchical
- Operated under district magistrate’s control
- Lacked public accountability
- Focused on coercion rather than crime prevention
- Little community engagement or service orientation
- Major Post-Independence Changes in Pakistan
✅ A. Police Order 2002
- Replaced Police Act 1861
- Introduced under Pervez Musharraf’s regime
- Key features:
- Operational autonomy from the executive
- Creation of Public Safety Commissions
- Establishment of Police Complaints Authorities
- Separation of investigation from operations
- Merit-based appointments for senior police roles
✅ B. Specialized Units
- Anti-Terrorism Departments (CTD)
- Dolphin Force (Punjab), Rapid Response Forces
- Women Police Units, Cybercrime Wings (FIA)
✅ C. Technological Upgrades
- E-policing, digitized FIRs, Safe City projects in Lahore & Islamabad
- Use of surveillance cameras, GPS tracking, police apps
✅ D. Training & Capacity Building
- National Police Academy, provincial police training colleges
- Courses on forensics, cybercrime, counterterrorism, and community policing
- Persistent Challenges
- 🧱 Outdated structures in many regions still mirror colonial hierarchy
- 🎭 Political interference in appointments and postings
- ⚖️ Lack of public accountability and transparency
- 👥 Poor police-community relations due to abuse and corruption
- 💰 Underfunding, weak training, and poor service conditions
- 🧾 Failure to fully implement Police Order 2002 across all provinces
- Recommendations
- 📜 Revive and implement Police Order 2002 with constitutional safeguards
- 👮♂️ Depoliticize police through merit-based transfers and autonomy
- 🔍 Strengthen internal accountability mechanisms and independent oversight
- 🧠 Focus on community-oriented policing to rebuild trust
- 🏢 Modernize police infrastructure and digitize investigation procedures
- 🎓 Invest in training on human rights, gender sensitivity, and forensics
- Conclusion
The colonial foundations of Pakistan’s police force continue to shape its functioning today—authoritarian, hierarchical, and politically influenced. However, through constitutional reform, technology, training, and citizen-centered policing, this legacy can be transformed. A modern police force must act not as masters over the people, but as servants of justice and peace.
“The future of policing in Pakistan lies not in controlling people—but in serving them with dignity and fairness.”
Q. No. 6. What are the legal and ethical guidelines for investigating gender-based crimes? Explain your answer with the help of suitable examples.
Outline:
- Introduction
- Definition of Gender-Based Crimes
- Importance of Legal and Ethical Safeguards
- Legal Guidelines in Pakistan
- International Legal Standards
- Ethical Principles in Investigation
- Key Examples
- Challenges in Implementation
- Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
Gender-based crimes (GBCs) such as domestic violence, rape, acid attacks, honor killings, and harassment are violations not just of law but of human dignity and equality. Investigating such crimes requires sensitivity, confidentiality, and adherence to legal and ethical norms to protect victims and ensure justice.
“Justice in gender crimes begins with dignity in investigation.” — UN Women Report, 2021
- Definition of Gender-Based Crimes
Any harmful act directed at an individual based on gender, including physical, sexual, psychological, and economic harm.
Most GBCs disproportionately affect women, girls, and marginalized genders.
- Importance of Legal & Ethical Safeguards
- Protects victim dignity and rights
- Ensures fair trial and due process
- Prevents secondary victimization (re-traumatization by law enforcement)
- Strengthens public trust in the justice system
- Legal Guidelines in Pakistan
✅ Pakistan Penal Code (PPC)
- Section 375–376: Rape laws
- Section 509: Sexual harassment
- Section 337: Acid attacks
- Section 302: Honor killing (treated as murder post-2016 amendment)
✅ Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2016
- Made honor killings and rape non-compoundable (can’t be forgiven by family)
✅ Protection Against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act (2010)
- Provides legal redress through ombudsperson mechanism
✅ Anti-Rape (Investigation and Trial) Act, 2021
- Establishes special courts, gender-sensitive investigation units, and use of modern tools (DNA, videography)
- Mandatory female medical and legal officers for victims
- Fast-track trials in 4 months
- International Legal Standards
- CEDAW (Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women)
- UN Declaration on the Elimination of Violence Against Women (1993)
- Istanbul Convention (Council of Europe)
- UNODC Guidelines on Investigating Violence Against Women
- Ethical Guidelines in Investigation
Principle | Explanation |
👩⚖️ Victim-Centered Approach | Prioritize victim’s comfort, agency, and protection during investigation |
🔒 Confidentiality | No public disclosure of survivor’s name, identity, or sensitive information |
👩⚕️ Gender-Sensitive Personnel | Female officers/doctors to record statements or perform medical exams |
🧠 Trauma-Informed Care | Investigators must be trained to handle psychological distress and PTSD |
⚖️ Informed Consent | Medical and legal procedures must be explained and approved by the victim |
🧾 Evidence Integrity | Ensure collection of physical evidence (e.g., DNA, clothes) follows legal chain |
📹 Use of Technology | Videotaped statements to reduce courtroom trauma and manipulation risks |
- Examples
- Zainab Case (Kasur, 2018):
- Swift DNA-based investigation, public pressure → led to Anti-Rape legislation
- Qandeel Baloch Murder (2016):
- Triggered honor killing reforms; previously crimes could be forgiven by heirs
- Minar-e-Pakistan Incident (2021):
- Exposed police inaction, victim-blaming → demand for trauma-informed response
- Challenges in Implementation
- 👮♂️ Lack of trained, gender-sensitive officers
- 🧬 Poor forensic infrastructure and DNA delays
- 📉 Victim-blaming and social stigma
- ⏳ Delays in trial, low conviction rates
- 🧾 Poor legal awareness among women and police
- 🔇 Pressure from families or community elders to withdraw complaints
- Recommendations
- 👩🏫 Train police, judges, and prosecutors in gender-sensitive laws and trauma care
- 🏥 Improve access to female medical staff, forensic labs, and rape kits
- 🧑⚖️ Establish dedicated GBV courts in all provinces
- 📣 Launch awareness campaigns about rights and redressal mechanisms
- 🧑🤝🧑 Partner with civil society for survivor support and legal aid
- 📜 Enforce Anti-Rape Act 2021 and expand its coverage nationally
- Conclusion
Gender-based crime investigations must go beyond the routine to ensure justice with empathy. While Pakistan has introduced strong legal frameworks, their implementation remains inconsistent. A shift toward victim-centered, rights-based, and trauma-informed policing is essential for a just society.
“How we treat survivors defines the justice of our system.” — UN Women Pakistan, 2022
Q. No. 7. What is meant by forensic criminal investigation? What are the hurdles in streamlining the forensic criminal investigation in Pakistan?
Outline:
- Introduction
- Definition of Forensic Criminal Investigation
- Scope and Importance
- Key Types of Forensic Evidence
- Forensic Institutions in Pakistan
- Major Hurdles in Effective Forensic Investigation
- Case Examples
- Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
In modern criminal justice systems, forensic science has revolutionized evidence collection and case resolution. Forensic investigation enables objective, scientific, and court-admissible proof, ensuring justice is based on facts—not speculation. However, in Pakistan, forensic investigation remains underutilized and inconsistent due to systemic challenges.
- Definition of Forensic Criminal Investigation
Forensic criminal investigation refers to the scientific analysis and interpretation of physical, biological, and digital evidence collected from a crime scene to help identify, apprehend, and convict offenders.
- Scope and Importance
- Links suspects to crime scenes through biological or material evidence
- Provides objective and reliable evidence in court
- Helps in cold case resolution, postmortem analysis, and crime pattern identification
- Supports counterterrorism, cybercrime, narcotics, and sexual assault investigations
- Key Types of Forensic Evidence
Type | Use in Criminal Investigation |
🔬 DNA analysis | Identifying suspects from blood, hair, or semen |
🧤 Fingerprinting | Matching latent prints at scene to databases |
🔫 Ballistics | Tracing bullets and weapons used in shootings |
🧪 Toxicology | Detecting poisons, drugs, or alcohol in victims |
📱 Digital forensics | Extracting data from phones, computers, or CCTV |
🧣 Trace evidence | Fibers, soil, or materials transferred during the crime |
- Forensic Institutions in Pakistan
- 🧪 Punjab Forensic Science Agency (PFSA) – most advanced facility
- 🧬 National Forensic Science Agency (NFSA) – under Ministry of Interior
- 🔍 Forensic labs in Karachi, Quetta, and Peshawar
- 👮 Limited mobile crime scene units under provincial police
- Hurdles in Forensic Investigation in Pakistan
🔹 A. Infrastructure & Resource Gaps
- Very few fully equipped labs (PFSA is an exception)
- Most provinces lack modern forensic labs
- Overburdened staff, outdated tools, and limited mobility
🔹 B. Shortage of Trained Personnel
- Lack of qualified forensic experts (DNA, cyber, ballistics)
- Crime scene evidence is often mishandled by untrained police
🔹 C. Poor Crime Scene Management
- Evidence contamination due to lack of scene cordoning
- Inadequate chain of custody protocols
- Delays in evidence collection and transportation
🔹 D. Legal & Procedural Challenges
- Courts sometimes disregard forensic evidence due to weak documentation
- Delays in forensic reports cause judicial backlogs
- Lack of standard operating procedures (SOPs) for all provinces
🔹 E. Financial Constraints
- Forensic labs are underfunded and dependent on provincial budgets
- Modern equipment and reagents are expensive and imported
🔹 F. Coordination and Awareness Issues
- Weak cooperation between police, prosecutors, and forensic teams
- Lack of awareness among judiciary and public about value of forensic proof
- Case Examples
- Zainab Rape-Murder Case (Kasur, 2018):
- Solved through DNA matching, showcasing value of PFSA
- Sahiwal Encounter (2019):
- Delayed forensic results and weak evidence chain harmed justice delivery
- Cybercrime Investigations (FIA):
- Digital forensics hampered by slow extraction tools and lack of skilled staff
- Recommendations
Area | Suggested Action |
🧪 Lab Expansion | Establish forensic labs in every province and major city |
👨🔬 Capacity Building | Train police, prosecutors, and judges in forensic literacy |
🔄 Standardization | Implement uniform SOPs for evidence collection and storage |
📊 Data Integration | Create national forensic and criminal database (AFIS, DNA) |
💰 Increased Budget | Allocate special funding for lab equipment, vehicles, and staff |
📚 Legal Reform | Make forensic evidence central to investigation and trial |
📱 Digital Upgradation | Invest in cyber labs, phone forensics, and encryption tools |
- Conclusion
Forensic science is the bedrock of modern evidence-based policing. Pakistan’s criminal justice system must shift from witness-based to science-based investigations. Though PFSA is a strong model, scaling such capacity nationally—with trained manpower, laws, and infrastructure—is essential to deliver justice that is scientific, swift, and certain.
“In a world of lies, forensic evidence speaks only the truth.”
Q. No. 8. What is the role of community policing in curtailing the problem of crime in Pakistan?
Outline:
- Introduction
- Definition of Community Policing
- Core Principles of Community Policing
- Role in Crime Reduction
- Benefits in the Pakistani Context
- Current Initiatives and Examples
- Challenges to Implementation in Pakistan
- Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
Traditional policing in Pakistan has largely been reactive, authoritarian, and disconnected from the community. In contrast, community policing offers a collaborative, trust-building approach that involves citizens and law enforcement working together to address the root causes of crime. This model is especially vital in urban crime zones, conflict-prone areas, and regions with low police credibility.
- Definition of Community Policing
A strategy where police and community members collaborate to identify, prioritize, and solve local crime problems through partnership, problem-solving, and proactive policing.
It emphasizes decentralized decision-making, transparency, and citizen empowerment.
- Core Principles of Community Policing
- 👥 Police-community partnership
- 🧠 Problem-solving orientation
- 🏘️ Decentralized command
- 📢 Two-way communication and transparency
- 🤝 Respect for cultural and local values
- Role in Crime Curtailment
Function | Impact |
🚓 Local patrol and presence | Deters crime through visibility and familiarity |
🧠 Early threat detection | Citizens report suspicious behavior before crime occurs |
🗣️ Improved intelligence | Community provides accurate and timely information |
🤝 Conflict resolution | Minor disputes are mediated before escalating to violence |
👨👩👧 Youth engagement | Prevents radicalization and criminal recruitment |
🧘 Reduces fear of crime | Citizens feel safer and more cooperative with authorities |
- Benefits in the Pakistani Context
- 🏙️ Addresses urban issues like street crime, gang activity, and drug abuse
- 🎯 Promotes targeted policing in high-risk zones (e.g., Karachi, Lahore)
- 🕌 Involves mosques, schools, elders, and civil society in peacekeeping
- 👨🎓 Builds trust in youth, preventing radicalization and violence
- 📣 Counters public perceptions of police brutality and corruption
- Current Initiatives in Pakistan
- ✅ Safe City Projects (Lahore, Islamabad) with surveillance and public cooperation
- ✅ Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Police Reform introduced community liaison officers
- ✅ Dolphin Force in Punjab: Community-focused patrolling
- ✅ ICT Police Mobile App: Citizen-police engagement and complaint tracking
- ✅ Thana Culture Reform efforts in Sindh and Punjab to make police stations citizen-friendly
- Challenges in Implementation
- 👮♂️ Colonial police mindset—still command-driven, not service-oriented
- 🎭 Political interference in policing undermines trust
- 💸 Lack of resources for proper community policing units
- ❌ No formal training in community engagement or human rights
- 📉 Public distrust due to past abuse, bribery, and custodial violence
- 🧱 Weak legal framework to institutionalize community policing
- Recommendations
Area | Suggestion |
👨🏫 Training | Train officers in soft skills, negotiation, and human rights |
🧱 Structural reform | Establish Community Policing Units at each police station |
📱 Digital engagement | Use mobile apps, SMS alerts, and social media for public feedback |
📢 Awareness campaigns | Promote the idea of shared safety via schools, mosques, media |
🧾 Legal backing | Amend police laws to make community policing a legal mandate |
🤝 NGO and civil society partnerships | Leverage local networks for conflict resolution |
- Conclusion
Community policing is not merely a technique but a philosophy of shared responsibility. In a country like Pakistan—where law enforcement is under-resourced, distrusted, and overburdened—community policing offers a transformative model. By building trust, decentralizing control, and engaging citizens, it can help create safer, more peaceful, and just neighborhoods.
“When the police become part of the community, crime becomes the outsider.”
Q. No. 9. Discuss the role of FIA in controlling organized crimes in Pakistan.
Outline:
- Introduction
- Understanding Organized Crime
- Introduction to FIA
- Core Mandate and Jurisdiction
- Key Departments Addressing Organized Crime
- Major Organized Crimes Handled by FIA
- Achievements and Operations
- Challenges Faced by FIA
- Policy Recommendations
- Conclusion
- References
- Introduction
Organized crime is one of the most dangerous threats to internal security, economic stability, and public trust in the state. In Pakistan, crimes such as human trafficking, cybercrime, money laundering, immigration fraud, and terrorist financing have evolved into network-based, cross-border operations. The Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), established to counter such threats, plays a crucial role in the prevention, detection, and prosecution of organized crimes in Pakistan.
- Understanding Organized Crime
“Organized crime is a structured group engaged in significant illegal activities for profit or influence.” – UNODC
Organized crime typically involves:
- Coordination among multiple offenders
- Cross-border elements
- Use of violence, corruption, or deception
- High economic and societal impact
In Pakistan, this includes:
- Human smuggling
- Cyber fraud
- Money laundering
- Fake documentation
- Terrorist financing
- Narcotics and arms trafficking
- Introduction to FIA
The Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) was established under the FIA Act, 1974. It operates under the Ministry of Interior and is mandated to investigate:
- Federal crimes
- Transnational crimes
- White-collar and financial crimes
- Cyber-related and immigration offenses
FIA serves as Pakistan’s primary federal-level law enforcement agency, with both investigative and prosecutorial powers.
- Core Mandate and Jurisdiction of FIA
FIA’s jurisdiction includes:
- Enforcement of immigration, passport, and customs laws
- Investigation of financial frauds, cybercrimes, and terrorist financing
- Coordination with Interpol and other global agencies
- Implementation of FATF recommendations and anti-money laundering actions
- Support to law enforcement in complex and high-profile cases
- Key Departments Addressing Organized Crime
Department | Primary Focus |
Immigration & Anti-Trafficking Wing | Smuggling, trafficking, forged travel documents |
Cyber Crime Wing (NR3C) | Hacking, fraud, online harassment, cyber terrorism |
Economic Crime Wing | Bank fraud, fake currency, money laundering |
Counter-Terrorism Wing | Investigates terror financing and extremist financing networks |
Interpol Wing | Handles red notices, cross-border fugitives, global crime cooperation |
- Major Organized Crimes Tackled by FIA
✅ Human Trafficking and Smuggling
- FIA identifies smuggling routes and agents
- Coordinates with IOM and Interpol
- Investigates trafficking networks preying on desperate migrants
✅ Cybercrime
- NR3C unit handles over 100,000 complaints per year
- Includes online banking fraud, identity theft, cyberbullying, and hate speech
✅ Money Laundering and Terror Financing
- FIA has traced illegal remittance channels (hawala/hundi)
- Collaborates with FATF, SBP, and law enforcement
- Handles high-profile white-collar investigations
✅ Immigration and Passport Fraud
- Detects forged documents, blacklists repeat offenders
- Prevents illegal migration and repatriates victims of trafficking
- Key Achievements and Operations
- Kasur Child Abuse Scandal: FIA provided forensic and cyber support
- Zainab Rape-Murder Case (2018): Assisted in DNA tracing and digital profiling
- Anti-Hawala Operations: Helped identify illegal money channels, improving FATF compliance
- Cybercrime Crackdowns: NR3C arrested hundreds in cases of fraud, blackmail, and digital piracy
- Challenges Faced by FIA
⚖️ Legal and Structural Challenges
- Overlapping jurisdictions with NAB, police, CTDs
- Outdated laws not adapted to new types of digital or cross-border crimes
👨💻 Human Resource Deficiency
- Shortage of forensic, cyber, and financial crime experts
- Limited training in advanced international investigation techniques
🛠️ Technological Limitations
- Lack of modern tools for cyber forensics and surveillance
- Underutilized forensic labs outside Punjab
📊 Data and Coordination Gaps
- No centralized national criminal database
- Weak intelligence sharing between provinces and agencies
💼 Political Interference and Corruption
- Sensitivity of high-profile cases sometimes leads to delays or compromises
- Lack of autonomy limits action against elite-linked crimes
- Policy Recommendations
Area | Recommendation |
🧠 Human Capital | Recruit and train cyber, forensic, and financial crime experts |
⚖️ Legal Reform | Amend FIA Act and related laws to reflect modern crime challenges |
💻 Technology Upgrade | Equip FIA with AI-based surveillance, blockchain tracking, and cyber tools |
🔄 Interagency Coordination | Integrate with NADRA, police, customs, and banks via a centralized system |
🧾 Accountability | Establish independent internal audit and public complaint mechanisms |
🌍 Global Cooperation | Expand MoUs with Interpol, Europol, UNODC, and FATF |
💬 Public Awareness | Educate citizens on reporting cybercrime, trafficking, and scams |
- Conclusion
The FIA is at the forefront of Pakistan’s fight against organized crime, operating in a fast-evolving criminal landscape. With rising digital crimes, financial frauds, and human smuggling, FIA’s role is more important than ever. While it has made commendable progress, its success depends on its autonomy, modernization, and inter-agency coordination. A robust and empowered FIA is essential to ensure national security, justice delivery, and global trust.
“To dismantle organized crime, the system must be more organized than the criminal networks.”
. . Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022 Criminology 2022